The Frank Report

The truth is always fair

Frank Report
The truth is always fair

More MK10Art From Sara Bronfman to Ben Myers to Kristin Kreuk

02/21/2020  |  AnnaMercury
More MK10Art From Sara Bronfman to Ben Myers to Kristin Kreuk
SharefXin

MK10ART has produced more splendid artwork on the theme of Nxivm and its various characters.

See more of her artwork  

As we often do when presenting MK10ART’s work, Frank Report will publish the art, followed by MK10ART’s comments, which are often, but not always, taken from Frank Report stories.

This is followed by *** and then my comments.

Kristin Kreuk Compared to Ghislaine Maxwell?

Is Kristin Kreuk the Miss Ghislaine of Nxivm?Is Kristin Kreuk the Miss Ghislaine of Nxivm?

New information about #kristinkreuk ‘s involvement with pedophile #keithraniere and her #Nxivm offshoot #girlsbydesign #gdb will be published soon on Frankreport.com and it will be scandalous. Stay tuned…

***

While there is much more to learn, no doubt, about Kristin Kreuk’s role in Nxivm and especially Girls By Design, the source that promised me a bombshell turned out to be a hoax.

The source told me that Kreuk had molested her when she was 14 and also forced her to endure sex with Keith Raniere.

The source told a compelling tale, with lots of details including the names of some of the other women involved.

She told a touching bit about how Allison Mack sympathized with her and tried to help her.  The story fell apart, however, at one crucial part.

I asked her where Raniere molested her and the source said it was in Vancouver. That was a red flag for me. Raniere was not known to travel. I asked Susan Dones, Sarah Edmondson and Kristin Keeffe if any of them knew if Keith had ever gone to Vancouver. All three of them emphatically said no.

It seems the story is most likely a hoax.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Lauren and Keith Imprison Dani

#LaurenSalzman testified in court about her helping #Nxivm leader #KeithRaniere keep a girl named Daniella prisoner in a room.

Lauren: And honestly, I was very incredibly discompassionate with her and I was unkind often. At times, I punished her. You know, it was terrible.

Q How do you feel about participating in this now?

Lauren: I think it’s horrendous. I — of every — of all the things that I did in this case and the crimes that I committed, too, I think that this is the worst thing that I did. I — I don’t know what to say. I kept her in her room for two years, and I didn’t even go visit her most of the time. And I wasn’t that nice to her and it’s awful.

Q What happened to the letters that Daniella wrote to the defendant (Raniere) while she was in the room?

A Well, initially, me or her family members would photocopy them for her to keep a copy and then I would take a copy to Keith, but he asked me to hold them. So I held most of them. And he gave some to #NickiClyne after he was — or after he left — or when he left for Mexico. And then after he was arrested, I photocopied and made them available [to the prosecution.

***

Yes, Lauren was pretty cruel to Daniella and I am glad she admitted it in court.

However, I think that if Raniere was somehow released from prison and Lauren was freed of potential imprisonment and if it were offered to Lauren tomorrow that she could accept Raniere’s sperm for an avatar baby in return for imprisoning Daniella for 100 years, Lauren would do it.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Clare and Alex and Hapless Mexican Attorney

Mexican attorney Diego Ruiz Duran (right) was retained by Alex Betancourt, (center) and paid by Clare Bronfman (left), to threaten DOS slaves who wanted to escape. #keithraniere and #ClareBronfman (sister of #SaraBronfman ) had their flying monkeys send threatening letters to former #Nxivm members, telling them that they will be thrown in jail.

#ClareBronfman is now being sued by attorney Neil Glazer for vexatious litigation among other crimes.

***

Most likely Mexican attorney Diego Ruiz Duran did not know what he was getting into. He saw a good-paying client in Alex Betancourt and followed his lead sending out stupid threatening letters to Betancourt’s targets and collecting fees.

I think it is terribly interesting that Betancourt is not named in Neil Glazer’s civil lawsuit.

That must mean he is helping, possibly agreeing to act as a witness for the plaintiffs.

I love the expressions MK10ART captured on Betancourt, Bronfman and of course the hapless Ruiz Duran.

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Basit and Sara on the run

Au revoir France. #Nxivm members #SaraBronfman and her husband #basitigtet fled France when the news broke they were running a children’s school-based on convicted felon #keithraniere teaching. (Keith is a pedophile) How long will they last in #portugal?

***

Speaking about loving the expressions on the faces of MK10ART’s subjects, no photo could capture the greedy perfidy of Basit and Sara better than does this sketch, in my opinion.

The couple has fled France and is reported to be in Portugal. Sources with information will be telling us more in the coming weeks of their Portugal adventure.

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Nxivm Couple

#BenMyers (married to the daughter of Nxivm president #NancySalzman ) Gets Job With Chinese Communist Party-Backed Company Doing EEG Experiments on Children; Left Under Suspicious Circumstances

***

This sketch tells it all. From the little Keith Raniere pubic brand above the gruesome couple’s head to the little children with EEG machines attached to them as they study, and overlooking them is the Nxivm horror couple, Ben Myers and Michelle Salzman-Myers.

Once again, look at their faces and expression. MK10ART has really captured who they are. Forget the phony pretense of being interested in life coaching and humanity. And the over-toothy smiles seen in photographs.

These folks, the leaders of Nxivm, were in it for the spoils. And Ben Myer, during his stint with the Chinese Communist Party-backed BrainCo, was using all his years of Raniere-deception training to do harm for profit.

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Tourette’s Cure?

#Nxivm leaders #NancySalzman and #KeithRaniere claimed to have cured Tourrettes Syndrome with their brain experiments. #ClareBronfman produced a short propaganda film about it shown at film festivals. See the clip on YouTube https://youtu.be/RBbx3p1UbEc

***

I did speak to one woman who told me that Nancy did help cure her Tourette’s. Whether she just naturally got better or whether Nancy really helped her, I am in no position to say.

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Human Fright with Dr. Brandon ‘Mengele’ Porter

The specific cause of Porter's loss of license was because he conducted studies dubbed "human fright" which the licensing board were conducted without informed consent and proper protocols.The specific cause of Porter's loss of license was because he conducted studies dubbed "human fright" which the licensing board were conducted without informed consent and proper protocols.

#drbrandonporter performed illegal fright studies on uninformed #Nxivm members. He was working for the Ethical Science Foundation which was paid for by #ClareBronfman

***

A great painting capturing the pure joy Dr. Brandon “Mengele” Porter must have experienced watching women freak out when he showed them his videos. He told some of the women that he was going to show them something on a video related to Raniere’s teaching.

How right he was.

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

EEG Testing

“In 2016 and 2017, 25 Americans, including CIA agents, who worked in the U.S. Embassy in Cuba suffered serious brain injuries causing impaired vision and memory loss among other persistent problems.

Now we have learned that at least 15 American officials in China suffered unexplained brain trauma soon after. As we first reported in March, the FBI is now investigating whether these Americans were attacked by a mysterious weapon that leaves no trace.

Over many months, we have been collecting evidence of what appears to be a hostile foreign government’s plan to target Americans serving abroad and their families.” https://www.cbsnews.com/news/brain-trauma-suffered-by-u-s-diplomats-abroad-could-be-work-of-hostile-foreign-government-60-minutes-2019-09-01/

Though #Nxivm Hacker #BenMyers Is Fired, Chinese Communist BrainCo Still Selling Suspect EEG Headbands for Children at Catholic Memorial School in Roxbury MA

***

One of the most chilling things that came out of the Ben Myers working for BrainCo story is not Ben Myers, but that the biggest slave state in the world, China, is controlling a company headquartered in Boston that is distributing EEG headbands to children in America – and the EEG data might be sold and might cause trauma to children based on faulty metrics.

If that is not cause for concern, I do not know what is. It is certainly a lot more troubling than what a rascal like Ben Myers might be doing at this job or another.

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Queen of sadism


Abusive and Vexatious Litigation


In support of the #NXIVM criminal enterprise and in furtherance of its objectives, Defendants grossly misused legal systems in the United States, Canada, and Mexico to conceal their wrongdoing, silence critics of NXIVM, punish defectors, and terrorize current NXIVM members with the omnipresent threat of having to defend themselves against frivolous lawsuits and spurious criminal complaints if they left the program.

Clare Bronfman paid for the lawyers NXIVM hired to wage the enterprise’s reign of legal terror. She also drafted threatening letters that were supplied to NXIVM’s lawyers to transpose onto law firm letterhead and then sent to the targets of the enterprise’s wrath.

Defendants’ legal abuses included filing false criminal complaints with law enforcement authorities, bringing and maintaining baseless civil litigation, vexatious and sanctionable litigation tactics, perjury, manufacturing evidence, and witness tampering.

In about 2009, Defendant #ClareBronfman began directing the formulation, funding, and execution of the enterprise’s legal strategy, subject only to Defendant #KeithRaniere ’s ultimate approval.

With her limitless resources, almost anything Raniere wanted could be accomplished, and examples of their litigation abuses abound.

One tactic they employed was to intervene and interfere in the bankruptcy proceedings of members who had exhausted their life savings and become deeply indebted to NXIVM, either in pursuit of the Stripe Path or in unsuccessful attempts to open their own NXIVM centers, and who then filed for personal bankruptcy in order to discharge their debts.

In several cases, the Defendants asserted baseless fraudulent claims or objections to the debtors’ financial disclosures, seeking to deny the member a discharge. Defendants also employed abusive discovery tactics designed to prolong the proceedings and increase the expense …
Read more at https://frankreport.com/2020/02/16/glazer-lawsuit-exposes-clare-bronfman-to-life-imprisonment-on-possible-sex-trafficking-charges/

***

There is not much more to add except to say that MK10ART really captured the smile of joy that sinister Clare Bronfman displayed whenever she knew she was going to sue and ruin someone.

All in all, this is another great collection of paintings and sketches of the historic group of human animals who all swarmed around one insane leader, Keith Alan Raniere – and so many of them continue to pay the price.

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


SharefXin

Comments (19)

  • AnonymousMarch 11, 2026
    The real story here may be simpler: a huge settlement created a pool of money and a network of professionals formed around it. Therapists, administrators, trustees, advisers — everyone gets a slice. Once that ecosystem forms, nobody inside it has an incentive to question the original story that created the money.
    • AnonymousMarch 13, 2026
      The system ran like a containment camp. A judge that once worked at psU then pimped to be a county Da. moved into a judge role and ran the system like a practicing lawyer. He was a crook and not the smartest of much. If you had a choice to review the cases that were botched you'd say this county combo was shit stain of fuckery.
    • J MoodyMarch 15, 2026
      That is so interesting. Initially McGettigan's telling young protoge's at his law firm (as it mentions in his Obit) when they would ask if Sandusky was really guilty, he'd exaggerate “Guilty as hell!” which is the required prosecutorial attitude … even if a prosecutor has doubts. And settlement money after the trial wasn't related to any injustice … after his wife was getting the 5K per year minimum from being a trustee, though, in videos he seems to act like he thinks JS really was guilty, and he allowed himself to forget that a *former* witness collecting settlement money is unlikely to ever tell the truth if it means the money will stop. Over time, his wife's salary from the settlement money reduced his curiosity about the facts of the case.
      • AnonymousMarch 16, 2026
        I tried to find an article from wayback about the one judge connected. It was about this judge falling asleep in court. And the writer was sued and paper and I think the judge got over three hundred grand and it was shady, It was right after the judge went thru a divorce. I think he envisioned everyone naked In the room and feed his ego into thought while seated behind the bench.
  • AnonymousMarch 11, 2026
    Fucking right I too hope Sandusky dies in prison or by rope of choice. I no Howard stern wants him clipped.
  • Score KeeperMarch 12, 2026
    Yawn.

    Say Hi to Jer for me!

    And tell him not to drop the soap!
  • Pimps for PadenMarch 12, 2026
    Recently found this random photo of Jerry Sandusky at my parents house;
  • Sheldon Lee KociolMarch 12, 2026
    Jerry Sandusky needs to be freed.

    [redacted]
    • Sheldon Lee KociolMarch 30, 2026
      The fog in Salinas didn’t just roll in from the Monterey Bay; it clung to the lettuce fields like a damp shroud, turning the neon signs of Main Street into blurred, glowing ghosts. In a nondescript converted warehouse tucked between an agricultural cold-storage facility and an old rail line, Sheldon Lee Kociol adjusted his prayer shawl.

      It wasn't the traditional wool of his ancestors. It was woven from charcoal-colored silk, embroidered with silver thread that seemed to catch the light even when there was none.

      Sheldon looked out over his congregation. These weren't the “Satanists” of cinema—there were no capes or flickering torches. These were the weary and the sharp-eyed: field foremen with dirt under their fingernails, disillusioned tech commuters from across the grade, and poets who had run out of metaphors.

      “Welcome,” Sheldon said, his voice echoing with a calm, scholarly weight. “Let us begin the mid-week reckoning.”

      He didn't preach about evil. To Sheldon, the “Synagogue of Satan” was a misnomer for the misunderstood—a place for the adversarial spirit, the ha-satan of the old texts who acted as the heavenly prosecutor, the one who asked the difficult questions. In the heart of the Salad Bowl of the World, Sheldon’s role was to help people harvest their own truths.

      He opened a heavy, leather-bound volume. “Tonight’s reading is from the Book of Doubt,” he announced. “We live in a valley of plenty, yet we are starved for meaning. We are told to be humble, yet we are ignored. I say to you: the only sin is the refusal to see yourself as the architect of your own fate.”

      The air in the room grew heavy with the smell of damp earth and expensive incense. Sheldon moved to the bimah, his shadow stretching long and thin against the back wall. He spoke of the balance between the light of the sun that grew the crops and the darkness of the soil that birthed them.

      As the service ended, the congregants filed out into the chilly California night. Sheldon stayed behind, blowing out the candles one by one. He walked to the window and watched a freight train rumble past, its whistle screaming into the mist.

      He allowed himself a small, wry smile. Being a rabbi in Salinas was one thing; being a guide through the shadows was quite another. He tucked his silk shawl into a velvet case, locked the heavy steel doors, and vanished into the fog, just another silhouette in the valley.
      • AnonymousApril 3, 2026
        Danish, plagiarizing Steinbeck and impersonating someone who has nothing to do with your insanity is rich. WTF is wrong with you Danish. Don’t you have enough legal problems? I just looked up the synagogue of Satan and it’s an antisemitic book. That makes you Danish a antisemite which is a hate crime. That is beyond civil suits. I also looked up, which is public domain, all synagogues in Salinas and Monterey County. There is not one called synagogue of Satan. There is no rabbi named Sheldon Lee Kociol.

        You are a sick pathetic little man Danish who is trying to get into more legal trouble. You really have a mental disorder. You are a sick pathetic coward.
        • AnonymousApril 22, 2026
          It is not Danesh, it is Samuel K from Nebraska. He is a verifiable mentally disturbed retard. He has been arrested for sexual assault of a 7 year old girl. In other words, Samuel is a verifiable pedophile. Samuel impersonates minor children on TikTok. He doesn’t have a life or job. He sponges off his wife. He is criminally insane and extremely racist.
          • Sheldon Lee KociolMay 7, 2026
            No idea who Samuel Kociol is. Perhaps you are confusing him with me. I was arrested for SAing a 7 year old boy. You sound like that psycho Cortney Kotzian. I told you to stop bothering me. I am not interested in your two boys.
        • Sheldon Lee KociolMay 7, 2026
          The Synagogue of Satan is located at 24 Pine Street in Salinas and I, Sheldon Lee Kociol am the Radical Rabbi. Stop by and join me for a service.
  • AbmMarch 12, 2026
    Sandusky deserves a new trial. Period.
  • AnonymousMarch 12, 2026
    I have been a lawyer for 22 years, and a public servant for almost all of that time. I have not retained an attorney to advise me to speak, or to remain silent. I am an attorney.

    i_challenge_ag_kane_to_face_me.html
  • AnonymousMarch 12, 2026
    McGettigan: May he enjoy the warmer climate he just relocated to.
    • AnonymousMarch 16, 2026
      Sandusky is innocent. ANyone who strudies the case will see it.
  • AnonymousMarch 12, 2026
    “When you’ve finally had enough of the status quo and decide to become the main characters of your own neon-purple fever dream. Business as usual? Not today. We’re taking the luggage, the fur, and the first flight out of Finaville.”

    Screenshot-2026-03-12-at-7-08-45-AM.png
  • AnonymousMarch 21, 2026
    (3) Just as concerning is that not only does the Board hide information from the public and deliberate in private, Board leadership even hides information from some trustees who are merely trying to fulfill their fiduciary responsibilities.

    — Nothing but low life scum bags that sit on these corrupt boards and play games of hiding information/evidence from each other.

    Special Interests agendas are what’s priority in Pennsylvania.

    https://www.statecollege.com/articles/opinion/op-ed-5-reasons-to-worry-about-how-penn-states-board-of-trustees-university-leadership-continue-to-conduct-business/

    Op-Ed: 5 Reasons to Worry About How Penn State’s Board of Trustees, University Leadership Continue to Conduct Business

    By

    Alvin de Levie



    March 19, 2026 – 1:52 pm

    Latest Penn State News, Opinion

    I was quoted in a column in October 2024 when I stated the Penn State Board of Trustees and university leadership had lost their way. Sadly, it has only gotten much, much worse.

    (1) In a brazen and unprecedented attempt to circumvent and in defiance of the Pennsylvania Right To Know Law (RTKL) and in an attempt to hide from the public communications sent to trustees who were state agency secretaries appointed by the governor, it was suggested and discussed by trustees that such emails be sent only to their private email addresses, not to their official state email addresses, all in the hope that those emails would not be subject to a RTKL request.

    It was also suggested and discussed by trustees that information sent to those secretaries also be sent through Diligent, a cloud based platform, again in a calculated attempt to shield such communications from a RTKL request. I personally heard all this from board members while I was on campus for a board meeting. At the time, I was a member of the Penn State Board of Trustees.

    The Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court wholly rejected this attempt by Penn State, noting that ruling otherwise “would perversely incentivize Commonwealth agencies, local agencies and affected third parties like Penn State to utilize remote servers and/or cloud-based services, in order to ensure that they would no longer need to disclose what would otherwise constitute public records.”

    To allow Penn State to utilize remote and/or cloud-based services would enable the university to dodge Pennsylvania transparency laws. Sadly, but not surprisingly, Penn State and the Pennsylvania Department of Education sought review of the decision in which the Commonwealth Court ruled Penn State cannot shield records from the public simply by storing them in a file-sharing system or alleging they contain proprietary information.

    In the petition to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court seeking review of the lower court decision, Penn State claimed that although the secretaries had access to and could review the records on the cloud-based server, that the gubernatorial appointed trustees actually never received the records. HUH?

    So although those trustees had access to the records, could read them, think about them and read as many times as they wanted to, they never possessed them? HUH?

    Penn State claimed that since the materials on the server could not be “xeroxed,” to use an ancient term, the trustees appointed by the governor did not possess the records and were therefore not subject to a RTKL request. And yet, it was common practice for trustees to have “xeroxed” copies of the documents before, during and after trustee meetings. So the Penn State argument is fatally factually and legally flawed.

    Sadly, Penn State revoked access by the governor’s appointees to the online file-sharing platform. To the best of my knowledge, there has been no explanation by the Penn State administration, by the Board of Trustees or by the individual secretaries whose access has been revoked whether they have otherwise been provided the materials necessary for them to conduct university business. If not, what are the ramifications of these trustees not having access to the information necessary for them to fulfill their fiduciary responsibilities? And if they received the records, how and when did they?

    (2) After years on the Board, either former Board of Trustees Chair Mathew Schuyler did not know about and did not have the foggiest or faintest understanding of how and why the Pennsylvania Sunshine Law applied to Board deliberations, or worse perhaps, he knew, but did not care and/or felt the Board was above the law.

    The Sunshine Law required the Board to fully deliberate IN PUBLIC — not behind closed doors in executive session with debate hidden from the public — before it voted on the $700 million appropriation for the renovation of Beaver Stadium, which many times has been referred to by the university as the largest appropriation in Penn State history.

    Due to the significant public interest and the magnitude of committing Penn State to a $700 million obligation (at the time I was a member of the Penn State Board of Trustees and chair of the Legal and Compliance Committee), I explained to former Chair Schuyler the Board needed more time to deliberate IN PUBLIC. Chair Schuyler did not heed my advice and cut short public deliberation, stating the Board had ample time to deliberate in executive session… meaning in private, behind closed doors, hidden from the public.

    Spotlight PA (an independent newsroom in Pennsylvania, focused on investigative and public service journalism) cited the conversation between myself and former Chair Schuyler in a lawsuit it filed alleging the Board of Trustees violated the Pennsylvania Sunshine Law. Rather than face certain public ridicule and scrutiny from an adverse court decision, the Board agreed to send all of its members to school to be taught the importance of and why the Board must comply with the Pennsylvania Sunshine Law.

    Well, I was not on the Board when trustees “went to school” to learn about why it is important for them to adhere to the Sunshine Law. Isn’t it sad and disappointing trustees even had to “go to school” to learn about the importance of public deliberation and the applicability of the Pennsylvania Sunshine Law?

    So why is public deliberation, discussion and debate by the Board critical? This issue was discussed and addressed in a recent Spotlight PA story. It quoted a statement of Ross Mugler, interim president and CEO of the Association of Governing Boards of Universities and Colleges: “Public discussion can improve trust and help leaders make better decisions. When board members spend meaningful time in discussion, institutions benefit from the candid dialogue and healthy skepticism that occurs before final decisions are made. Quick approvals without inquiry fall short of fiduciary duty. Leaders must encourage questions, test, assumptions, and explore alternatives before decision-making.”

    (3) Just as concerning is that not only does the Board hide information from the public and deliberate in private, Board leadership even hides information from some trustees who are merely trying to fulfill their fiduciary responsibilities.

    An alumni-elected trustee asked Board leadership for information regarding Penn State’s approximate $5 billion endowment because of his concerns regarding expenses charged by endowment managers, and the performance of the endowment investments. One of the trustee’s concerns was that management costs and fees had tripled. This trustee wanted to examine records, including an IRS form, to see if there was an explanation.

    Maybe there was a good explanation; maybe not. But that really doesn’t matter one way or the other. It is pretty straightforward: The trustee was entitled to review the documents he requested. If there was a problem with the endowment, all the better to find out. If there was no problem, all the better.

    The trustee also sought documents regarding the university’s award of a contract to Elevate Sports Ventures, a professional ticketing sales agency for Penn State football games.

    Board leadership and the chair of the finance committee refused to give the information to their colleague even after the trustee asked for the information about a half dozen times. So in July 2024, the trustee filed suit in Centre County Court requesting the information in accordance with state law. Finally, in February 2025, Board leadership agreed to give their fellow trustee the information that they themselves certainly had access to.

    I am certainly not privy to what any review of those documents revealed. But regardless of what a review of the financial documents and contract revealed, the documents should have been released to the trustee without the necessity of his filing suit.

    (4) Has board governance overall become more transparent? Sadly, no. While the Penn State Board of Trustees has actually spent more time discussing certain university business in its public meetings in 2025 than in previous years, that does not tell the whole story. In those full public meetings, data analyzed by Spotlight PA reveals that all but five minutes of the board’s public conversations in 2025 were almost entirely regarding only three topics: naming the field at Beaver Stadium; removing a sitting trustee from the board who requested information regarding the university endowments, ostensibly for other reasons; and closing seven branch campuses.

    From review of the Board’s full public meetings in 2025, Spotlight PA found such topics as the Penn State strategic plan, the university’s annual operating budget (about $10 billion) and President Neeli Bendapudi’s compensation package and raise of approximately $1 million received 29 seconds of public discussion.

    In all fairness to the board, in addition to full public board meetings, committees meet in public sessions where various matters are certainly discussed. But again, that does not tell the whole story. In those public committee meetings, committee members, who are handpicked by the board leadership, can ask questions, and when and if time permits, other trustees can ask questions, BUT only if called upon by the Board chair.

    And if you believe the full board met extensively in public in 2025, you would be wrong, again. According to an analysis conducted by Spotlight PA, the full board met in public nine times in 2025 for a total of approximately 10.5 hours.

    The Board acts as if it is a privately owned and closely held corporation, which owes no accountability to the public, the constituencies of Penn State and the commonwealth that appropriates $300 million annually to Penn State.

    (5) So you might hope things could not get worse. Sadly, you would be wrong again.

    You might think and hope trustees who have not had a full opportunity to ask questions or have a fulsome discussion and opportunity to deliberate during public meetings could talk freely and directly with the public and/or press to express their thoughts, concerns and opinions. But censorship and Big Brother live at Penn State. Let me explain.

    A recent change to the Board’s bylaws muzzles direct and unfettered communication by trustees to the university’s constituencies: the students, the staff, alumni and the entire Penn State community. The recent change states trustees “shall coordinate media and press interactions relating to matters that have come before the Board with the Board office in advance and shall respect guidance regarding such interactions that might be conveyed by them or the office of strategic communications.” In other words, say what Big Brother wants or face censure, or worse, expulsion.

    So what does all this mean?

    Board leadership that failed to adhere to the PA Sunshine Law, that failed to adhere to the PA Right To Know Law, that withheld information from a trustee only trying to do his job, and that restricted public deliberation regarding the $700 million renovation of Beaver Stadium has truly no shame nor accountability. Big Brother lives at Penn State.

    It also means that the Board of Trustees and university leadership dictate what you know and what you hear because they want to control what you think. In the meantime, we can all look forward to the “puff pieces” trustees and university leaders routinely post on LinkedIn and other social media, while we are force-fed countless promotional articles from the Office of Strategic Communications.

    SO WHAT CAN YOU DO?

    Experience teaches us Penn State will not voluntarily change how they conduct business. Will contacting the Board of Trustees and university leadership change anything? Probably not. Experience teaches us they don’t care. Why do I say that? Because in 2021, the Penn State Board of Trustees banned in-person public comment and discussion. Was the criticism too strong or were they simply unprepared to answer the tough question? OR did they not want to explain what they were doing. It was just another way they could insulate themselves and not be held accountable.

    This is not about politics. It’s about good governance and transparency. This is an election year. Contact the candidates for governor, state representatives and state senators repeatedly and and ask them to hold Penn State accountable by (1) amending the Pennsylvania Sunshine Law to include serious financial penalties and sanctions if Penn State does not adhere to the letter of the law; (2) amending the Right To Know Law to make it to make it more broadly, applicable to Penn State and again to include serious financial penalties and sanctions if Penn State does not adhere to the Law. AND, continue to seek accountability from individual trustees, the president and all those on the president’s council.

    Alvin de Levie is an attorney and former member of the Penn State Board of Trustees.

Leave a comment

More From The Frank Report