Hypocrisy in Action: Soares Investigating Cuomo – Part 2

P. David Soares

In Part 1 of this series, I pointed out how hypocritical I thought it was for P. David Soares, the Albany County District Attorney, to have announced last week that he was going to investigate whether New York State Governor Andrew M. Cuomo sexually assaulted and/or harassed one or more the women who have claimed that he did so.

P. David Soares

Not only has Soares failed to prosecute any of the numerous corrupt elected officials who committed crimes while they were serving in office in Albany, NY during his 16+ year tenure, he has also allowed – and some would even say aided and abetted – the NXIVM/ESP sex cult/criminal enterprise throughout the entire time he’s been in office.

Had Soares simply done his job – and investigated any of the numerous complaints his office received about what was going on at NXIVM/ESP’s corporate headquarters at 455 New Karner Road –  it’s quite likely that Keith Raniere, one of the co-founders of NXIVM/ESP, would never have created Dominus Obsequious Sororium, the secret society that resulted in the branding of scores of women with Raniere’s initials: KAR.

Examples of the infamous KAR brand

And had Soares ever investigated the numerous illegal activities that NXIVM/ESP carried on in Albany County, it’s also quite likely that many people – including me – would not have had their lives so disrupted and shattered by the fraudulent and vexatious litigation that Raniere used to harass and silence anyone he perceived to be a threat to his criminal empire.

Initially, Soares may have been reluctant to investigate NXIVM/ESP because several of his family members – two sisters and a brother-in-law – had taken some of NXIVM/ESP’s training programs.

But Soares most certainly decided to leave the cult alone after he agreed to meet with Clare Bronfman – and other representatives from NXIVM/ESP – in 2007 to hear why they wanted him to indict me (The real purpose of the criminal action was to pressure me into settling a civil lawsuit that several prominent members of the NXIVM/ESP cult had previously initiated against me).

Clare Bronfman is currently incarcerated in a federal prison in Philadelphia

District Attorneys usually don’t sit in on such meetings – especially when there’s already an active civil lawsuit going on between the parties – but, then again, Soares is not your usual D.A. (Although he had served as an Assistant District Attorney for Albany County for several years before he ran for office, his official title of “Community Prosecutor” belies the fact that he rarely saw the inside of a courtroom before he was elected as Albany County District Attorney – and has rarely been inside one since he took office in 2005).

At the time he first met with Bronfman, Soares was totally dependent on the political funding that he received from the Working Families Party. In agreeing to meet with Bronfman, he had to be thinking just how much easier it would be for him if he had his own source of virtually unlimited funding for future campaigns.

After meeting with Bronfman and other representatives of the NXIVM/ESP sex cult, Soares cobbled together a one-count indictment against me based on claims from Bronfman that I had stolen money from one of the foundations they controlled. That indictment was thrown out shortly after the presiding judge held the first hearing in the case – and had an opportunity to review the “evidence” that Soares relied upon in seeking the indictment.

Although Raniere pressed Soares to re-indict me on some other charges, that never happened – at least not then. Raniere and Bronfman then hired Frank Parlato to, among other things, get me re-indicted – an assignment that he turned down after he and I met to discuss the merits of the claims against me.

An artist sketch of Raniere during his trial

Several years later, however, Soares would, once again, try to curry favor with Raniere and Bronfman by indicting me – and two other individuals – on charges that he knew were bogus.


The Bogus Computer Trespass Charges

In October 2013, NXIVM/ESP brought a civil lawsuit against me; former Time Union reporter James M. Odato, who had written numerous stories about the cult – including the award-winning series entitled “Secrets of NXIVM”; Suzanna Andrews, a freelance journalist who had written a story about the cult that was published in Vanity Fair “The Heiresses and the Cult”; and Raniere’s former girlfriend Toni Natalie, who at that time was going by the name “Toni Foley”.

The essential charge in the lawsuit was that the four of us had illegally accessed the server which hosted NXIVM/ESP’s website – and that we had stolen information from it including a list of people who had taken its training courses.

That civil lawsuit was dismissed in September 2015 when, along with the attorneys representing Jim and Suzanna, I pointed out to the court that the lawsuit was filed after the applicable statute of limitations had passed. All the motions to dismiss were based upon documentation that had been provided by Kristin Keeffe who worked tirelessly – and many believe put her life at risk – to expose the fact that the civil lawsuit was based on a lie.

Apparently, Clare Bronfman had forgotten that she had testified in an unrelated case on  September 21, 2011 – a little more than two years before the civil lawsuit was filed – that NXIVM/ESP suspected one or more people had already accessed the same server. The dismissal of the civil lawsuit likely saved Bronfman from being charged with perjury – a crime that she has committed on several occasions.

But although the civil lawsuit went away, there were also related criminal charges that had been brought against me, John Tighe, and Toni (Barbara Bouchey was added to the criminal case when, several months after it had been initiated, she allegedly accessed the same server via someone else’s credentials).

As has previously been reported in the Frank Report, the criminal computer trespass charges were totally bogus – and only came about because of a clandestine operation involving P. David Soares; the O’Connell & Aronowitz law firm (which was NXIVM/ESP’s primary legal representative at the time); and Rodger Kirsopp, a Senior Investigator with the New York State Police.

As previously summarized in the Frank Report, the “key facts” regarding those charges were as follows:

– In mid-2011, one or more representatives of NXIVM filed a complaint with the Office of the Saratoga County District Attorney alleging that John, Toni, and I had accessed its server without authorization.

– In April 2012, Raniere, Bronfman and Nancy Salzman – filed a similar complaint with the New York State Police and Kirsopp was assigned as the lead investigator on the case.

Rodger Kirsopp – He started out investigating NXIVM but ended up investigating its “enemies”.

– For the next eight months, Kirsopp worked closely with Saratoga County Assistant District Attorney Jesse Ashdown to put together a prosecutable case against John, Toni, and me.

– During the course of his investigation, Kirsopp received “evidence” of the alleged unauthorized computer accessing from Ben Myers and Steve Ose – both of whom had told him that they were independent contractors who provided IT services to NXIVM but who never told him that they were, in fact, hard-core, committed members of the cult.


Ben Myers


Steve Ose

– Throughout the investigation, Kirsopp had numerous meetings with – and numerous phone calls with – three attorneys from the O’Connell & Aronowitz law firm: i.e., Steve Coffey, Pam Nichols, and Mike McDermott (Both Coffey and McDermott previously worked in the Office of the Albany County District Attorney – and McDermott served as Soares’ Chief Assistant District Attorney just before he left to join the law firm).


Founding Member & Partner at O’Connell & Aronowitz


Pamela A. Nichols, Partner at O’Connell & Aronowitz


Mike McDermott, the President of O’Connell & Aronowitz

– On August 29, 2012, Kirsopp met with then Saratoga County District Attorney James Murphy to discuss the status of the investigation. During their meeting, they contacted Darren Miller, an Assistant NYS Attorney General, to discuss the possibility of having the Office of the New York State Attorney General take the lead on the case.

– On December 13, 2012, Kirsopp was notified (a) that the Office of the New York State Attorney General had decided not to get involved in the case because it did not think it could be successfully prosecuted: and (b) that the Saratoga County District Attorney was also closing out the matter.

So, that’s the end of the story, right? After almost two years of investigation, both of the entities that had looked at the allegations – and all the “evidence” that Myers and Ose had provided to Kirsopp – decline to move forward. So, case closed – and let’s move on to investigate some real crimes, right?

Nope…that’s not how the game is played in Albany County.

On January 9, 2013 – less than a month after the original investigation seemingly came to end –  Kirsopp was contacted out of the blue by Albany County Assistant District Attorney David Rossi ( I told you in Part 1 to remember his name!).

David Rossi, Chief Assistant District Attorney in Albany County

Rossi told Kirsopp that he had been contacted by Mike McDermott about the alleged unauthorized accessing of NXIVM’s server – and that his boss, P. David Soares, would possibly be seeking to have a Special District Attorney appointed to prosecute criminal computer trespass charges against John, Toni and me (Rossi explained that they wanted to use a Special Prosecutor because the Office of the Albany County District Attorney had a conflict-of-interest – which presumably had to do with its failed attempt to prosecute me back in 2007).

Although Kirsopp knew that the NXIVM server was actually located in Saratoga County – which is why he had been working with the Office of the Saratoga County District Attorney on the case since April 2012 – he apparently raised no questions with Rossi as to how and why Albany County had decided to intervene in the case.

And so, a criminal investigation that had come to an end was suddenly revived because P. David Soares wanted to do another favor for his favorite sex cult – and for his former sidekick, Mike McDermott.


In the next segment of this series, I’ll explain what happened after P. David Soares decided to get involved in the alleged computer trespass matter even though Albany County had no jurisdictional basis for doing so.

In the meantime, I want to reiterate that this would be an excellent time for the federal law enforcement officials in the Northern District of New York to get off their collective asses – and open an investigation into P. David Soares (I know that’s not likely going to happen but now that Antoinette T. Bacon has taken over as the Acting U.S. Attorney for the NDNY – and Janeen DiGuiseppi is now serving as the Special Agent in Charge of the FBI’s office in Albany, NY – I thought I’d give them a shot at doing what’s right here).


Antoinette T. Bacon, U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of New York


Janeen DiGuiseppi
Janeen DiGuiseppi, the Special Agent in Charge of the FBI’s office in Albany, NY


About the author

J.J. O'Hara


Click here to post a comment

  • Joe-

    I have enjoyed reading this series of articles.

    Is there any prosecutor’s office in the world that isn’t corrupt? (Rhetorical question)

  • “Hypocrisy in Action”

    So the perfect politician on paper. Pretty clear that is the reason he tried to join up with the Bronfmans to get access to their deep wallet until it became too toxic to do so. He probably ignored warnings it was a cult because all he heard was dollars calling. Now he thinks wading into the Cuomo shit pile will somehow make him electable. His bad call with the Bronfmans along with this one is a signal that, while he may have political ambitions, he doesn’t have the skills to see them through. Avoiding the Cuomo shit is an easy call. Statement against him is enough, pretending to go through motions is enough. Actually doing something, that sets him up for failure and a host of questions including a closer look at his background which I doubt is stellar.

    The Cuomo situation is going to get taken care of, just not in the way Cuomo thinks (dumbass egomaniac). The only reason it dragged out this long is Cuomo does still have power, COVID slowed things down and Democrats are just too damn polite about things (Sadly, they remind you why they have a reputation of not having a backbone on the regular). Ultimately, too many existing politicians can benefit from voting for and/or pushing his removal. Unlike Republicans, Democrats really don’t have a problem removing the too cancerous parts from the body. Emphasis on too cancerous since let’s be honest: all politicians, regardless of party, are cancerous.

  • An Internet search on Soares reveals nothing coming up on the 1st page about Nxivm/ ESP. Soares Wikipedia page does not mention the controversy.

    Joe, if you’re so committed to bringing Soares to justice, why have you not written on his Wiki page using Frank Report as a source material with links to Judge Garaufis’ comments?

    • Thanks for that suggestion (It’s not something I had even thought about). When I finish the current series, I will look into doing that.

  • Soares is investigating Gov. Cuomo. Cuomo may have the ability to disrupt this investigation by having Soares investigated for the very corruption you have mentioned here.

    So I wonder – Frank (because I know you hate those mother fuckin’ liberals), Joe, and Clav – if DiGuiseppi asked for your help, and you knew it would expose Soares and put him away, but at the expense of Cuomo’s case possibly being dropped, botched, or otherwise mishandled, and he might get off free, would you help her?

    • I believe that Cuomo will likely be removed from office via impeachment but I’ll set that belief aside and answer your question.

      Although I think that what Cuomo did is reprehensible and that he deserves to be prosecuted for what he did, I also think Soares is much more deserving of prosecution because he, in effect, sold his office to a criminal enterprise. Soares also violated his oath of office on numerous occasions — and aided and abetted criminal activity that eventually resulted in Raniere being convicted of seven felonies and five of Raniere’s cronies pleading guilty to assorted felonies.

      At the end of the day, Cuomo likely committed several misdemeanors — and deserves to be removed from office. But Soares’ illegal conduct is much more egregious.

      At least, that’s how I see it.

      • Casual readers of Frank Report may be unaware that Joe O’Hara was a predecessor of our host in being a business / legal / PR consultant to NXIVM, initially unaware of criminality. And when he became aware of criminality (in the scorched-earth pursuit of Rick Ross in the Sutton affair), he warned NXIVM that they were crossing the line, then left when they did not stop. NXIVM then called in favors from somehow compromised prosecutors like Soares until they eventually got a conviction on a dubious and certainly unrelated charge.

        I have always found his contributions insightful and credible.

      • Both are egregious. Being violated by a man, fearing losing your employment if you don’t comply is no small crime.

  • Joe:

    If you want to learn more about the charlatans, scoundrels, rascals and mountebanks who have run Albany for more than a century I recommend this book by William Kennedy:

    O Albany!: Improbable City of Political Wizards, Fearless Ethnics, Spectacular Aristocrats, Splendid Nobodies, and Underrated Scoundrels. New York: Viking Press, 1983.

    O Albany!: Improbable City of Political Wizards, Fearless Ethnics, Spectacular, Aristocrats, Splendid Nobodies, and Underrated Scoundrels Paperback – September 3, 1985
    by William J. Kennedy (Author)

    For those of you unfamiliar with Albany the Empire State Office Plaza is built on the site of Albany’s old Red Light District.
    And Albany is still infested with whores, both political and carnal.

    • When I first moved to Albany, Erastus Corning was still Mayor – he served for 41 years – and the Empire State Plaza was still under construction. Since I was working in government at the time, I got to see a lot of things that they didn’t teach in “Civics” class back in the day. But as wild as those times were, no one would have tolerated what Raniere got away with for almost 20 years. There may have been a lot of corruption back then but law enforcement officials weren’t morally bankrupt like they are now.

    • I won’t go into detail about this on a public forum but one of the funniest stories about the Empire Stare Plaza has to do with New York State taking over the land on which it’s built — and Corning’s response. I’ll figure out some way to share that info with you if you promise not to make it public.

  • It really is mind-boggling that the NDNY prosecutors have still done nothing to follow up on the charges that were referred to them by the EDNY. Especially after Judge Garaufis publicly called them out for letting Raniere run his criminal organization for almost two decades right under their noses. And it doesn’t sound like they’re going to do anything about David Soares or Roger Kirsopp or the crooked lawyers from OConnell and Aronowitz. Makes me wonder what sort of crimes they do prosecute.

  • If even half of what O’Hara says is true — and I’m inclined to believe all of it is — it really underscores just how crooked law enforcement is in Albany. Where else in the country could a DA use his office to support a sex cult operation and still be in office? Raniere chose wisely when he decided to set up his criminal operation in that sinkhole of corruption. Birds of a feather…

  • Just a brief comment to say how I love learning all of this from Mr. O’Hara, and his writing this series about N.Y. political creeps, and writing so incisively, while encoutering, exposing corruption, is wonderful to read.

    I am loving this, as well as seeing it as highly informative, intelligent, deep and defiant. Thanks so very much.

  • I know it’s a catty thing to say but the O&A law firm apparently doesn’t update its website very often. Otherwise, I’m sure Pam Nichols’ bio would feature a picture of her that was taken sometime during this century.

About the Author

Frank Parlato is an investigative journalist.

His work has been cited in hundreds of news outlets, like The New York Times, The Daily Mail, VICE News, CBS News, Fox News, New York Post, New York Daily News, Oxygen, Rolling Stone, People Magazine, The Sun, The Times of London, CBS Inside Edition, among many others in all five continents.

His work to expose and take down NXIVM is featured in books like “Captive” by Catherine Oxenberg, “Scarred” by Sarah Edmonson, “The Program” by Toni Natalie, and “NXIVM. La Secta Que Sedujo al Poder en México” by Juan Alberto Vasquez.

Parlato has been prominently featured on HBO’s docuseries “The Vow” and was the lead investigator and coordinating producer for Investigation Discovery’s “The Lost Women of NXIVM.” Parlato was also credited in the Starz docuseries "Seduced" for saving 'slave' women from being branded and escaping the sex-slave cult known as DOS.

Additionally, Parlato’s coverage of the group OneTaste, starting in 2018, helped spark an FBI investigation, which led to indictments of two of its leaders in 2023.

Parlato appeared on the Nancy Grace Show, Beyond the Headlines with Gretchen Carlson, Dr. Oz, American Greed, Dateline NBC, and NBC Nightly News with Lester Holt, where Parlato conducted the first-ever interview with Keith Raniere after his arrest. This was ironic, as many credit Parlato as one of the primary architects of his arrest and the cratering of the cult he founded.

Parlato is a consulting producer and appears in TNT's The Heiress and the Sex Cult, which premiered on May 22, 2022. Most recently, he consulted and appeared on Tubi's "Branded and Brainwashed: Inside NXIVM," which aired January, 2023.

IMDb — Frank Parlato

Contact Frank with tips or for help.
Phone / Text: (305) 783-7083
Email: frankparlato@gmail.com


Discover more from Frank Report

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue Reading