Just Because They May Have Fought Nxivm Does Not Make Them Saints

NXIVM teaches Executive Success Programs.

Editor’s Note: In the interest of honest exchange, I am publishing this comment by Bangkok AKA the Retard as its own post. I have published Bangkok calling me an asshole on numerous occasions and just so I don’t appear too biased, I let him voice his opinion that Joe O’Hara is also an asshole, that Barbara Bouchey is an emotional wreck, and that Toni Natalie benefited from her association with Raniere. Bangkok’s opinions are his own and not necessarily the opinion of the editor. Your response is welcome. 

By Bangkok

Frank Report finally published an unbiased post  – Why Weren’t Some Potential Witnesses Called By The Prosecution? that accurately criticizes Toni Natalie, Irish Barb Bouchey, and even Saintly Joe O’Hara.

I Can’t Believe That Photo of Joe O’Hara

Joe O’Hara in handcuffs in court.

Holy fuck! He looks like an aging biker and a homeless thug.

Joe, why the fuck did you choose to look like a homeless biker and a thug? How many street brawls have you been in?  Say it ain’t so, Joe.

My opinion of Joe O’Hara has forever changed after seeing that photo.

Unlike other people, I do believe you can judge a book by its cover.

Joe, I have no doubt that you were an unsavory asshole way back then. I have no doubt that you were aligned with the dark side of the force. You were probably Darth Vader’s right-hand man.

You’re no longer a ‘saint’ in my mind.


Barbara Bouchey wept when she learned about the verdict in the Keith Raniere trial.

What About Irish Barb Bouchey?

Irish Barb is an emotional disaster. If she had been called to the witness stand, she would have made Keith seem sane by comparison.

She’s an emotional wreck.

She’s got so much excess ’emotional baggage’ that even an entire team of psychological bellhops couldn’t lug that shit up to her room.


MK10ART Toni Natalie and Keith Raniere

What About Toni, the Saintly Italian?

Toni Natalie was one of Keith’s top salespeople in Consumer Buyline. She lived with Keith for years, benefiting from the proceeds of that SCAM. I’ve never heard her publicly apologize for ruining so many people’s dreams. I’ve never heard about her making financial amends with those victims.

Toni is no victim here. Except in her own mind (and perhaps Frank’s).

Frank, you need to start letting us express honest opinions and stop protecting your ‘favored’ people in this story.

About the author

Frank Parlato


Click here to post a comment

Please leave a comment: Your opinion is important to us! (Email & username are optional)

  • Well there are relevant issues raised. Inconvenient yes but all the same. CB was a scam that was profited from and so on.

  • Bangkok, are you per chance in any way affiliated with a Thai place next to Red Violet Rebel clothing store across from the Plaza in Thousand Oaks, CA?

    I ask bc the last time I happed to be near there in search of untainted food for my son at P.F. Chang’s in the Plaza, the back door to Chang’s was flung wide open and a vehicle bearing new, temporary plates with a camera mounted on the dash was parked right in front of it. While over at “Bangkok’s” someone was frantically waiving at a group that passed by us while we awaited our food order.

    Among that group was a disabled “client” from Dylan’s (former) program who shall go unnamed, who recently suffered an allergy attack at program due to being served peanut M&M’s by one of the coaches who was apparently not aware of his allergic condition or that peanuts are not allowed at program.

    [The paramedics had to be called in to attend to the poor lad over that program incident at a park. Oddly enough, a few days later, a scattering of red peanut M&M’s mysteriously appeared under my couch when I moved it to clean where caregivers never tread nor sweep nor mop; but they of course knew nothing of the origins of the red peanut M&M’s. I believe I recalled an incident concerning Keith Raniere’s fascination with Pavlovian M&M games Gina H. once related to me I posted or sent in — I don’t always check if Frank posted or not — here on FR shortly before these nutty incidents.]

    Also, while Dylan and I waited our food order outside Chang’s, a very young little girl sporting bright red lipstick was deliberately stopped and physical turned by an older girl to face Dylan’s much coveted vehicle (a Mercedes Sprinter adapted for his use) who pointed us out to the little girl being used in this harassment ploy. Frankly, I felt worse for the little girl being used and taught hatred, prejudice and manipulation than for Dylan who was laughing about the whole pathetic scene.

    I then drove over to “Bangkok’s” and waited for our “Mexican” to arrive on cue which he did, wearing a bright green shirt (which as Paul on here proclaims is a mark of the cruelest of NX criminals). I videotaped the scene for an independent film project, Frank has the Director’s cut though it’s since been edited on my “device.”

    So it would not surprise me if Bangkok’s VPN happened by sheer coincidence to hail from that very Thai place next to Red Violet Rebel across from the TO Civic Arts Plaza. Also, recently — a couple of months ago — my “devices” were apparently linked together and made interchangeable through a contact, a former program coach named “Violet,” in my contact list. Know anything about that, Bang baby? If you happen to, I suspect you could be getting a call from the “FBI” — the real one — not the “Fucked up Beyond Imagination” version who have contacted me in recent years and even once showed up to check my router when I reported on-going suspicious activity after they instructed me to reboot.

    Say it isn’t so and NC Girl you are right on and funny as all get out whereas, Bangkok — all of you hired guns — best be charging a Prince’s ransom now that you’ve succeeded in putting my little prince Dylan in the evil clutches of NXIVM. I’m sure I’ve called you an asshole before so as not to risk “insanely” repeating myself — you’re, in fact, a smelly, certifiably insane, cowardly asswipe who doesn’t deserve to even sit on the same toilet as Joe, Frank, Toni, Susan, Catherine, myself, all the brave NX fighters you obviously despise for the having the courage and stamina you sorely lack. Enjoy your pay off. Why don’t you spend it on some really good, pure, high grade opium from Thailand?!

  • Cock you are so full of sh*t you must be being paid to do this.

    Great to see how pure of blood and soil America has become. Not.

    Why shouldn’t you call folk out for their ethnicity and any other fixed circumstance of birth?

    After all, it’s how your government behaves – in session- for the whole world to see.

    Kick em all out, America! All those dirty immigrants!! ….America?….no one left to answer?

    Oh, of course, that’d be because there is no f*cking body left!!!

    Joe, Toni, Barb, John, Catherine, Sara, Mark, Heidi, Tony, Frank, all of you active EX-NX, thank you for your bravery and persistence,

    You certainly deserve better than the nx minion cock’s pathetic character assassination.

  • What a trash heap of an “article.” Seriously who gives a goddamn about Barb and Toni’s ethnicity? Who? What is the point?
    What was the point of this article to begin with? Nobody is a saint in the NXIVM story, outside possibly Susan Dones and the child victims of Creepy Keith.

    But whatever their “sainthood” or lack thereof, Toni, Joe, and Barbara Bouchey were once associates of Keith Raniere. When they broke away from him, they were each targeted by him and his money mafiosa, Clare B. (Clare honey, if you’re reading this, you are just a bank account on legs to Keith, nothing more, except maybe a pity fuck), They spent hundreds of thousands of dollars, burned through their savings and went through hell because of a vengeful microdick (thanks Cami, for telling us all what we secretly suspected, size matters, and Keith isn’t very big. Oh, yeah, and he has erectile dysfunction! HAHAHAHAHA!) named Keith. If not for them, John Tighe, Catherine Oxenberg, Sarah Edmondsen, Mark Vicente and yes, Frank Parlato, Keith would never have been arrested.

    Frank, I get that you’re okay being called an asshole. And, here’s to you for your integrity in standing tall and letting people take potshots at you. I admit I have called you out, and for some reason, you still let me post here. But, it seems to me Barb and Toni ( and Heidi!) have been tormented enough. The same for Joe. Why not give these folks a break?

  • This post has zero substance; I fully support the First Amendment rights of all people and, therefore, support the author’s right to free expression, but saying “I don’t like this guy, because he looks like an old hippie…”, is nothing more than a cheap personal attack, not a rebuttal.

    • Velvet – Absolutely! Regarding the “aging biker” comment. I’ve known quite a few bikers In the UK and found them to be pretty intelligent, non-judgemental and to have a good sense of humour and hearts of gold. Unlike Bangkok.

  • Frank – While searching online for Brandon Porter I came across this ebook by Anthony Todd Arnold. You are mentioned and it could be libellous I thought I should let you know, in case you didn’t know about it. I’ll understand if you don’t publish my post.


  • Dearest Bangkok,

    Your insights and observations need some corrections.

    Joe looks less like a biker and more like a harmless Woodey Nelson.

    Irish Barbara looks more like an East German watching the wall come down circa 1990. East Germany was known for poorly engineered cars and shitty hair salons.

    Tonie Natalie has suffered as much or more than anyone in the Nxivm saga with the exception of the 3 people who allegedly died as a result of being directly or indirectly affected by Keith Raniere.

    Bangkok, a young man your age should spend more time trying to get laid and less time spent harassing individuals that fell victim to a psychopathic cult leader.

    Bangkok, you should be spending your summer playing video games, drinking beer, and chasing tail.

    In other words, be a normal teenager you little dipshit!!!! 😉

  • This article is yet more proof that Dennis K. Burke (Bangkok), the disgraced former United States Attorney from Arizona, Clare Bronfman’s lawyer, is still active in his role as a NXIVM representative, defending and promoting interests of the NXIVM enterprise.

    This is likely due to Burke’s provable, long-standing connections and ongoing loyalties to Emiliano Salinas, whom he met through Marco A. Lopez Jr., Mexican businessman Carlos Slim’s top man in the United States.

    Everything written in this comment is 100% true and verifiable.

    • Anonymous,

      Obviously, you are Bangkok trying feebly to get people to believe you’re Dennis Burke…..

      Bangkok you have been trying this tactic for a while…

      Who do you think you are fooling?

      You are not even fooling Shadowstate and Shadowstate is fooled by Pea Onyu, the most obvious troll on planet earth.

About the Author

Frank Parlato is an investigative journalist.

His work has been cited in hundreds of news outlets, like The New York Times, The Daily Mail, VICE News, CBS News, Fox News, New York Post, New York Daily News, Oxygen, Rolling Stone, People Magazine, The Sun, The Times of London, CBS Inside Edition, among many others in all five continents.

His work to expose and take down NXIVM is featured in books like “Captive” by Catherine Oxenberg, “Scarred” by Sarah Edmonson, “The Program” by Toni Natalie, and “NXIVM. La Secta Que Sedujo al Poder en México” by Juan Alberto Vasquez.

Parlato has been prominently featured on HBO’s docuseries “The Vow” and was the lead investigator and coordinating producer for Investigation Discovery’s “The Lost Women of NXIVM.” In addition, he was credited in the Starz docuseries 'Seduced' for saving 'slave' women from being branded and escaping the sex-slave cult known as DOS.

Parlato appeared on the Nancy Grace Show, Beyond the Headlines with Gretchen Carlson, Dr. Oz, American Greed, Dateline NBC, and NBC Nightly News with Lester Holt, where Parlato conducted the first-ever interview with Keith Raniere after his arrest. This was ironic, as many credit Parlato as one of the primary architects of his arrest and the cratering of the cult he founded.

Parlato is a consulting producer and appears in TNT's The Heiress and the Sex Cult, which premieres on May 22, 2022.

IMDb — Frank Parlato


Contact Frank with tips or for help.
Phone / Text: (305) 783-7083
Email: frankparlato@gmail.com